Joe's Pizza Broadway

K.Tanaka 4 weeks ago

Hands down one of the best pizza spots in NY 🍕 Stopped by at 6 PM on a weekday. No reservations for small groups, but plenty of space. Seated on the 2nd floor with a great view, sipping a perfectly balanced fruity IPA while taking in the aroma from the wood-fired oven below 🍻 Rule of thumb for NYC pizza: order one pie at a time so it stays hot and fresh! (Takes ~10 mins for the next pie to arrive). First up: Margherita. Super thin, crispy crust with generous, high-quality toppings. Absolute flavor bomb, especially with a pinch of red pepper flakes 🌶️ Second pie: Custom combo of Anchovies + Black Olives on a standard cheese base. After years of coming here and trying different toppings, I’ve officially found my all-time favorite. The salty, savory balance is perfection. $140 total including tip. Unreal value for this level of quality. What a night!

CK Yu (KeN) 2 months ago

If you’re looking for an authentic New York pizza experience, Joe’s Pizza is absolutely worth the visit. The line moved quickly, and the moment you step inside, you’re surrounded by decades of history with walls covered in celebrity photos, newspaper articles, and memorabilia that showcase why this place has become a NYC institution. We tried several slices: * 🍕 Pepperoni – Thin, crispy crust with perfectly balanced cheese and sauce. The pepperoni was slightly crisp around the edges and packed with flavor. * 🍅 Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato (Caprese) – Fresh tomatoes, creamy mozzarella, basil, and a drizzle of olive oil made this slice light, fresh, and delicious. * 🧀 Sicilian Cheese – Thick, fluffy, and loaded with gooey cheese. Comfort food at its best. The crust is what really stands out—crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, with just the right amount of char. Despite being incredibly busy, every slice tasted fresh and came out hot. The shop itself has that classic New York charm. Seating is limited and can get crowded, but that’s all part of the experience. Grab a seat by the window if you can and enjoy watching the city while eating one of NYC’s most iconic slices.

Aleksandra 2 months ago

Super full, big queue, what is understandable because place is famous. Service was nice, and tried their best. We were informed before that its minimum 20min waiting time. Pizza was huge. Cheese, sos, salami were delicious and good quality but dough was really dry, maybe just not for me, i am a fan of Italian pizza.

Maha 3 months ago

We had a nice experience at Joe’s Pizza on Broadway. Everything was good, and the long line was not an issue at all. They have separate lines for whole pies and slices—the slice line moves especially fast, while the whole pie line takes longer since the pies need time to be prepared. • Pizza: The slice was good with a classic New York style. For my personal taste, it could have used a little more salt, but overall the flavor and quality were enjoyable. • Service: Even with the busy crowd, the staff handled everything efficiently, and the lines moved much faster than expected. • Seating/Atmosphere: This location is more of a quick eat-and-go spot. There are no comfortable seats to sit, relax, and spend time. It’s perfect for grabbing a slice and continuing your day, but not really a place to hang out. • Amenities: There is no restroom or sink/hand-washing area available, which would have been helpful, especially when eating pizza by hand. • Overall Experience: A great place to experience a famous NYC slice. I enjoyed the visit and would come back again for a quick, classic New York pizza experience.

Highway Video 4 months ago

A must-visit if you’re in New York. Simple, classic and full of that authentic New York pizza vibe. The slices were fresh, cheesy and so good — exactly the kind of pizza you imagine having in NYC. Be prepared for a queue though. There’s almost always a line and the wait can easily be around 30–45 minutes, but the pizza is definitely worth it. Quick service once inside and perfect for grabbing a slice while exploring the city. Definitely lived up to the hype.